Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$1,175,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 328994 MLS ⋅ Aquapelago BLDG.
If you've been waiting for a St. George Island Plantation home with true Gulf views, a private pool, proven rental history, and exceptional value, welcome to Aquapelago. Just 200 steps from the beach, this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath retreat offers the ideal blend of coastal luxury, privacy, and investment potential, making it one of the best-value first-tier Gulf-view homes in the Plantation. The light-filled top-floor living area is designed to maximize the Gulf views, with expansive sliding glass doors opening to spacious decks perfect for sunrise coffee, evening cocktails, and salty breezes. The open-concept kitchen and dining area comfortably seats ten, making it ideal for entertaining family and guests. All three bedrooms offer direct deck access. Two king suites overlook the resurfaced private pool surrounded by lush tropical landscaping, while the oversized bunk room comfortably accommodates additional guests, making the home equally suited for family getaways and vacation rentals. Aquapelago is also a proven income producer, generating $104,386 in gross rental income in 2024 and $96,977 in 2025, with $72,279 already on the books for 2026 as of July 12, 2026, providing immediate income potential for the next owner. Recent upgrades include solar panels (2021) that help keep average electric costs around $150 per month, hurricane shutters (2022), a new HVAC system (2021), and a transferable flood insurance policy of just $1,079 annually. Additional features include covered parking, covered entry, a hot and cold outdoor shower, fish-cleaning station, and grilling area. Owners also enjoy the exceptional amenities of the St. George Island Plantation, including two community pools, a fitness center, tennis and pickleball courts, nature trails, a clubhouse, a private airstrip, and exclusive access to Bob Sikes Cut. A new buyer fee of 0.5% of the purchase price is payable to the Plantation Property Owners Association at closing.

1912 Nautilus Dr, St. George Island
$1,999,700
3 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 328880 MLS ⋅ Flamingo Bay BLDG.
Custom Built, BAY FRONT home with private dock. PRIVATE BEACH. NO MARSH to wade through. Excellent fishing! Reds and trout caught right off the dock! Top of the line appliances including: WOLF gas range, NEW refrigerator, BOSCH dishwasher, leather topped granite kitchen countertops. On demand water heater, and AC installed 2018, New Air Handler 2025. New septic blower, pump & control panel in 2020. NEW 2025 DRAIN FIELD. Brilliant Pine flooring & ceiling add to the beauty of this home. The fireplace and comfortable High End furnishings as well as the view of the BAY, make the perfect setting to watch sunsets. The Florida Room off the master bedroom adds to the privacy of the Master Suite. It shares an entrance to the attached BAY SIDE fully screened in porch with a extra long dining table, comfortable sitting area and a porch swing. With EXCELLENT VIEWS and ENTERTAINING this bay side porch has a kitchen window pass through, for all your culinary items. Wrap around hurricane shutters offer the protection needed for storms. The attached, drive through garage is a great place to store your boat, golf cart and all of your recreation items. NEW rip rap along the entire bay side shoreline. Sand Beach inside entire line of rip rap. The outdoor shower and a 1/2 bathroom are easily accessible on ground level. Take the NEW Lift/ Elevator up to the street side porch or either of the three stairways to reach the one level living space. Handicap accessible. Owners stay in the house several weeks throughout the year. INVESTORS - GREAT RENTAL!! Community offers: pickleball, tennis, two swimming pools, club house, weight room, bike path, air strip, security... Great opportunity to own this waterfront one of a kind, GORGEOUS, beautifully staged, FULLY FURNISHED home in the Plantation, on St. George Island. If uncompromising, High End Quality, is important to you, purchase this exquisite home! Projected 2026 income $100K. HOA Buy In fee .5% purchase price

1419 Dove Ln, St. George Island
$1,070,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 328407 MLS
Tucked among mature palms and native vegetation inside St. George Island's Plantation, this distinctive custom residence offers exceptional privacy, timeless architecture, and a setting unlike anything else on the island. Designed with Mediterranean influences and elevated construction, the home showcases a tile roof, soaring ceilings, abundant natural light, and architectural details throughout. This property includes a covered car port, golf cart garage & workshop space. Additionally, the backyard is set up perfectly for hosting, with a private fire pit & propane hookup already placed for your grill! The home has 4 bedrooms, with the master bedroom on the second level having a private balcony facing the Gulf. Call today for your opportunity to view on of St. George Island's most unique homes! All offers must be submitted using PropOffers.com.

1656 Forsythia Ct, St. George Island
$1,425,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 328286 MLS
Beautiful Waterfront Vacation Home for Sale “Come for the view — stay for the privacy, private dock, and boat slip.” Welcome to your dream coastal retreat. Nestled on a quiet waterfront cove with 210 feet of shoreline, this stunning 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home offers breathtaking, unobstructed views of Smuggler's Cove Bay, exceptional privacy, and direct water access with a private dock and boat slip. Set on a wooded one-acre lot, the home is surrounded by natural beauty and tranquility. Expansive picture windows fill the spacious living area with natural light while perfectly framing the spectacular waterfront scenery. Built in 1994 by renowned local builder Carl Hoffman, this home has been lovingly maintained and thoughtfully updated over the years. Unlike many vacation properties, it has not been rented in years and has instead been carefully cared for by a family who spend six months each year enjoying it as their seasonal home. Many upgrades are afforded you, including; hurricane shutters, newly replaced tin roof (2024), weathered cedar siding (power washed 2025), upgraded electrical box, whole house wired for generator (2018), Gas Fireplace, Water Heater replaced (2026), Sewer “Aerobic” septic tank, two car covered garage with 3 separate storage compartments, ample space for your perfect outdoor kitchen. All furnishings are negotiable. Located within The Plantation, a prestigious private gated community with 24-hour roaming security, residents enjoy exclusive amenities including: Private airfield. Community beach. Clubhouse. Swimming pool, Exercise room, Pickleball courts, Tennis courts This is a rare opportunity to own a beautifully maintained waterfront getaway offering privacy, comfort, and unforgettable views. Schedule Your Private Tour For more information or to arrange a showing, contact: Bill Zester Anchor Realty 973-650-3318 ________________________________________

1915 Smugglers Cove Rd, St. George Island
$1,150,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 327693 MLS
Second-tier St. George Island retreat just 225 steps from the beach, with the beach path only moments away. This private 3-bedroom, 4-bath home offers relaxed coastal living with a private pool, expansive decking, and peaceful wooded surroundings. The home features a newer roof and comes fully furnished with Regina Andrew lighting, Frontgate and Ballard Designs furnishings, and custom window treatments, making it move-in or rental ready. Inside, the open-concept living area flows into an updated kitchen with quartz countertops, double ovens, and a wine refrigerator—perfect for gathering after a day at the beach. The spacious primary bedroom includes a walk-in closet and room to unwind, while the second bedroom is currently set up as a kids' room with an attached flex space used as a sitting/TV area, offering versatility for a playroom, media room, or additional sleeping space. Multiple decks create inviting outdoor spaces, and the private pool provides the perfect place to cool off after a day in the sun. The property is professionally landscaped by Tallahassee Nurseries, enhancing the natural beauty and privacy of the setting. Ideal as a full-time residence, vacation getaway, or investment property, this home captures the best of island living. New Buyer fee .50% to be paid to SGPOA at closing.

1464 Bayberry Ln, St. George Island
$1,245,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 326517 MLS ⋅ Atlantis BLDG.
Update: $72,190 in gross rental on the books for 2026 as of 07/12/26. Welcome to island living at its finest. This beautifully renovated and fully furnished 5-bedroom, 4.5-bath Mediterranean retreat is tucked inside the gated community of St. George Island Plantation, just a short stroll from the sugar-white sand and emerald Gulf waters. With room to sleep 14, the home offers two spacious living areas perfect for gathering after long beach days, an open top-floor deck made for sunset skies, and a screened porch where you can relax and catch the coastal breeze. Inside, light-filled spaces blend comfort and coastal sophistication. Refinished hardwood floors, granite countertops, modern fixtures, updated hardware, polished metal railings, and refreshed bathroom lighting create a clean, elevated look that still feels relaxed and inviting. Thoughtful upgrades bring both efficiency and peace of mind. Solar panels installed in 2023 power the entire home—including the electric water heater—leaving only a minimal $30 monthly connection fee. A new water heater and a new aerobic septic system were also added, while hurricane shutters provide added protection and potential insurance savings. Step outside to your private pool, complete with a heater/chiller system for year-round enjoyment. New aluminum safety gates, a golf cart garage, and generous storage make beach days simple and stress-free. Located just 1,000 feet from the shoreline, owners enjoy all the amenities of St. George Island Plantation, including 24-hour gated security, two community pools, clubhouse, fitness center, tennis and pickleball courts, scenic bike paths, and even a 3,300-foot private airstrip. With strong rental history and impressive projections, this home offers the perfect blend of coastal comfort and income potential. Schedule your private showing today and start living the island life. New buyer fee of % to the Plantation Owner's Association.

2052 Whelk Way, St. George Island
$1,195,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 324635 MLS ⋅ The Top 'Sea Turvy Turtle BLDG.
Exceptional second-tier 4BD/3.5BA two-story home in the exclusive gated St. George Plantation. Set on a landscaped, partially wooded half-acre lot, this property offers privacy, space, and easy access to premier community amenities. The ground level features a welcoming entry, laundry, and generous owner's storage. The first level includes two guest bedrooms sharing a full bath—one with a bunk bed and full-size bed—plus a south-facing primary suite with an ensuite featuring a jetted tub and separate shower. The main upper level offers a spacious great room combining living, dining, and kitchen areas, a convenient half bath, and a north-facing guest bedroom with ensuite. Three of the four bedrooms open to expansive covered porches, creating seamless indoor–outdoor living and tranquil views. Exterior features include a private in-ground pool (with heater), shower, fish-cleaning station, multiple covered decks, and a short walk to the beach. The home has been lovingly maintained and has a solid rental history with repeat guests and excellent reviews. An elevator shaft is already built in and currently used as owner's closets. Just a 3-minute stroll leads to uncrowded white sandy Gulf beaches; a 5-minute walk brings you to Magnolia Clubhouse with an indoor fitness room, large 103,000-gallon pool, restrooms, covered pavilion with picnic tables, and a tennis court. Additional community amenities include a private airstrip, a second pool, two more tennis courts (three total), two pickleball courts, miles of bike paths, 24-hour roving security, underground utilities, and access to Bob Sikes Cut. Ideal for anyone looking for a serene coastal retreat on Florida's Forgotten Coast or an appealing investment opportunity, this home is ready to welcome you—schedule your private showing today! Please note, a new buyer fee of 0.50% of the purchase price is payable to SGPOA at closing.

1824 Denise Ct E, St. George Island